Marshall,
This version of an anaglyph "near red truck" is fine with me.
I didn't bother trying to make my version "near red" with alterations. I simply used the readily available "Optimize Anaglyph" selection with no additional tweaking. The version appeared to be to be near orange (to me) more than green, and didn't have R/R, so that was fine with me.
I can see when conversing with you, that my mistake was to include the word "Red" anywhere in the Title or text. I did that because I used the same title in both the X and A versions and it was meant as a referral to the original color of the truck. I should maybe have just said "Classic Truck".
As you and I both have stated previously, color is not that big a deal when it comes to anaglyphs (for us), especially when it comes to originally red subjects. My biggest concern there is reducing/eliminating R/
R.
I have not commented on most of your images since your return primarily because I was a little dismayed at your attempts to present images with subjects of red tones at the expense of R/R. Although you would probably respond back by saying you would rather me have commented on what I thought was wrong specifically, I really didn't want to get into it with you namely because your the man with years of experience and I thought you should already see what I see and if not, my telling you my opinon would not convince you otherwise. I'd just rather stay out of such confrontations where judging from past experience it usually doesn't resolve anything.
Cheers,
Brian
My Flickr page: http://www.flickr.com/photos/ur4chun8/
My photos according to "Interestingness"...
http://fiveprime.org/hivemind/Tags/Brian,Wallace,3d
My FAA Web page:
http://brian-wallace.artistwebsites.com/
Capture Outdoors Maryland: http://www.capturemaryland.com/users/Starg82343
To: anaglyphs(-at-)yahoogroups.com
From: mrubin(-at-)hvc.rr.com
Date: Thu, 23 May 2013 16:50:37 -0400
Subject: Re: [Anaglyphs] Classic Red Truck/Marshall
Brian--
I grabbed your X-view and
de-saturated it in PS to about -40 (while viewing with glasses) and then
imported the R and L chips
into SPM, processing w/o the
program's alteration features. The result as I see it is a truck that
although it's not a bright red is at least reddish. Do
you
think this sort of technique is
worth exploring for other normally red subjects?
Marshall
