I commented on that view and its FW because I thought
it
made for a worthy comparison to the other two from
that set of postings.
FW's don't fix, but sometimes hide ghosts, usually
with only moderate
success. I don't think it's wrong to use tools
to cover-up or even
eliminate flaws, but sadly, FWs mostly call attention
to such flaws,
robbing an otherwise worthy image of the greater
recognition it may deserve.
Marshall
Sent: Sunday, January 24, 2010 11:07 PM
Subject: Re: [Anaglyphs] (CAUTION:FW) was partly for you
Marshall
|
I read all of the floating window sparring that took
place in the last few weeks. As so many said, a floating
window is just another tool and does have a place in the creation of
anaglyphs. I honestly think that some posters could benefit from using
them once in a while. I use them only when I feel there are no
alternatives to fixing severe ghosting.
In this case the caution was a failed attempt at sarcasim. However I
speciffically recall Marshall stating that he would not comment on any
post using a floating window and that was in part my reason for the
caution. I would have prefered that he kept his promise.
Mainer
--- On Sun, 1/24/10, Marshall Rubin
<mrubin(-at-)hvc.rr.com> wrote:
From:
Marshall Rubin <mrubin(-at-)hvc.rr.com>
Subject: Re: [Anaglyphs]
Trail Blazing (CAUTION: FLOATING WINDOW)
To:
anaglyphs(-at-)yahoogroups.com
Date: Sunday, January 24, 2010, 10:32
PM
I like the splendid isolation of the first two
views that show Nature at its best. Sorry,
but
any view that requires a
cautionary introduction is best un-posted, or at least, made
available
off-line. This view simply induces
a lot of visual pollution. Although I've come to
grudgingly
accept the FW as a legitimate tool on
limited occasions, this view is not one of them.
I don't have any complaints about views where
the inclusion of people are appropriate
for the surroundings, like in an
urban setting, or elsewhere where people seem to
fit
right into the surroundings.
But in the Oyster River setting,
it's refreshing NOT to see people.
Marshall
Sent: Sunday, January 24, 2010 7:50 PM
Subject: [Anaglyphs] Trail Blazing (CAUTION: FLOATING
WINDOW)
|
Nothing special, but Brian asked if I had one of my
friend. This is Kyle looking for the best way through
heavy growth along the edge of the Oyster River. People are
rare in my posts.
Ghosts on the jacket were unacceptable without a FW.
Mainer |
|
